Back to Advanced source practice
AdvancedVery HardTITA Source: LaTeX
Geometry/Coordinate Geometry and Optimisation

Question

MCQ} In the coordinate plane, A=(0,0)A=(0,0) and B=(10,0)B=(10,0). A point P=(x,y)P=(x,y) with y>0y>0 is chosen such that the area of triangle APBAPB is exactly 2020 square units. Over all such points PP, the quantity PA+PBPA+PB attains its minimum value at a unique point PP^{*}. The value of PAPBPA\cdot PB at P=PP=P^{*} is:

%================================================================

Options

A

3636

B

4040

C

4141

D

5050

Answer

(C) 4141.

Detailed solution

Area constraint: [APB]=12ABy=1210y=5y=20y=4.[\triangle APB] = \tfrac{1}{2}\cdot AB \cdot y = \tfrac{1}{2}\cdot 10\cdot y = 5y = 20 \Rightarrow y = 4.

So PP lies on the horizontal line y=4y=4, with P=(x,4)P=(x,4) for some real xx.

Minimising PA+PBPA+PB on the line y=4y=4: Reflect A=(0,0)A=(0,0) across this line to A=(0,8)A'=(0,8). For any PP on the line, PA=PAPA = PA', so

$

PA + PB = PA' + PB \ge A'B.

$

Equality iff A,P,BA', P, B are collinear. AB=(100)2+(08)2=164=241.A'B = \sqrt{(10-0)^{2} + (0-8)^{2}} = \sqrt{164} = 2\sqrt{41}.

Line ABA'B: from (0,8)(0,8) to (10,0)(10,0), slope 0.8-0.8, equation y=80.8x.y = 8 - 0.8x. At y=4y=4: x=5.x = 5. So P=(5,4).P^{*} = (5,4).

\textbf{Computing PAPBPA\cdot PB at PP^{*}:} By symmetry of (5,4)(5,4) relative to A=(0,0)A=(0,0) and B=(10,0)B=(10,0):

$

PA = \sqrt{25+16} = \sqrt{41}, \qquad PB = \sqrt{25+16} = \sqrt{41}.

$

Hence PAPB=41.PA\cdot PB = 41.

Why this is CAT-level: The reflection trick is the canonical fast route, but the question disguises it -- students may try Lagrange multipliers, derivatives, or even ellipse properties (since PA+PBPA+PB constant defines an ellipse with foci A,BA,B, and we want the smallest ellipse touching y=4y=4). All routes converge, but the reflection method is by far the cleanest under time pressure. Wrong option (D) 5050 tempts those who compute PAPBPA \cdot PB at P=(0,4)P=(0,4) (a boundary candidate, 16116410.77=43\sqrt{16}\cdot\sqrt{116}\approx 4\cdot 10.77 = 43, close to but not 5050); wrong option (A) 3636 corresponds to P=(5,4)P=(5,4) but with an area constraint of 2525 (a misreading).

Answer: (C) 4141.

%================================================================