Back to MSQE practice
PEAMCQHard

2024 PEA Q26

Same setup as Q25, except now each country spends 2/32/3 of its expenditure on its own good and 1/31/3 on the foreign good. What is the impact on pp when EAE_A falls from 100100 to 7070?

Reveal answer and solution

Answer

C

Solution

  1. 1

    AA spends 2/32/3 of pEApE_A on wheat \Rightarrow wheat demand =2pEA/3p=2EA3=\dfrac{2pE_A/3}{p}=\dfrac{2E_A}{3}. BB spends 1/31/3 of EBE_B (in TV) on wheat \Rightarrow wheat demand =EB/3p=EB3p=\dfrac{E_B/3}{p}=\dfrac{E_B}{3p}.

  2. 2

    Wheat market clearing:

  3. 3
    2EA3+EB3p=200.() \frac{2E_A}{3}+\frac{E_B}{3p}=200. \quad (\star\star)
  4. 4

    Combined with 200p+250=pEA+EB200p+250=pE_A+E_B:

  5. 5

    Before (EA=100E_A=100): ()EB=3p(200200/3)=p(600200)=400p(\star\star)\Rightarrow E_B=3p(200-200/3)=p(600-200)=400p. Income identity: 200p+250=100p+400p=500pp=560.833200p+250=100p+400p=500p\Rightarrow p=\dfrac{5}{6}\approx 0.833.

  6. 6

    After (EA=70E_A=70): ()EB=3p(200140/3)=p(600140)=460p(\star\star)\Rightarrow E_B=3p(200-140/3)=p(600-140)=460p. Income identity: 200p+250=70p+460p=530pp=250330=25330.758200p+250=70p+460p=530p\Rightarrow p=\dfrac{250}{330}=\dfrac{25}{33}\approx 0.758.

  7. 7

    Thus pp decreases.

  8. 8

    \textit{Intuition:} With home bias, AA spends more of its income at home (on wheat). When AA reduces total expenditure, the world demand for wheat falls disproportionately (since AA's marginal propensity to import is only 1/31/3, while it was previously absorbing 2/32/3 of its spending on wheat). Hence wheat becomes relatively cheaper.

Answer structure / marking notes

With asymmetric (home-biased) preferences, the transfer problem is not neutral.

%=========================================================

Content note

Imported from public/resources/isi/msqe/solutions/pea/2024/ISI_MSQE_PEA_2024_Solutions.tex. Question wording is retained from the available local TeX source; incomplete option blocks or ambiguous source status are flagged for review.